[LISTENED TO: October 20, 2010] Dubliners Part II
This collection covers the last five stories from the book. They are all longer stories, especially the fantastic novella “The Dead,” which runs well over an hour. The titles included in Part II are:
A Painful Case
Ivy Day in the Committee Room
A Mother
Grace
The Dead
These last five stories look at (continuing the theme from my previous post) middle age and later life. The protagonists are all older, and as with the first part, they all must deal with harsh realities and even death.
“A Painful Case” is the first story in the book where the title doesn’t directly apply to the protagonist (even though, of course, it does). Mr Duffy is a solitary man. He goes out from time to time but is not really social. At a concert he meets Mrs Sinico and they form a friendship. Her husband approves of the friendship because he believes that Mr Duffy is really after their daughter. The relationship grows stronger and stronger and Mrs Sinico feels closer to him than she does to her husband. Then, Mrs Sinico make a gesture indicating she’d like a more intimate relationship. Mr Duffy is immediately turned off by this and vows to himself to see her no more. This leads to a quote that I assume is not original to Joyce, and yet it is still common today: “Love between man and man is impossible because there must not be sexual intercourse and friendship between man and woman is impossible because there must be sexual intercourse.” The strange thing about this story is that it then jumps ahead four years. We learn that Mrs Sinico took the dissolution of their friendship very hard indeed. And naturally, Mr Duffy is made to rethink his life choices. It’s yet another story of despair. (more…)




SOUNDTRACK: BARENAKED LADIES-“Fight the Power” (1993).










