[ATTENDED: August 1, 2025] Guster
My wife and I saw Guster in March of 2024 and again in January 2025. Did we really need to see them again seven months later? Yes! In part because those two previous shows were their We Have Eras Too tour and this wasn’t. And also because it’s Guster and we love them.
We also dislike the Stone Pony Summer Stage and the thought of going down the shore on a Friday night…? Sheesh. But things worked out wonderfully. There was minimal traffic and I found a parking spot close to the Pony!
We were so early we could get merch and still get within three people of the stage.
It turns out that many people were there for The Mountain Goats, so when their set ended, we were practically on the fence (in front of Adam for a change).
We weren’t expecting a wildly different setlist from a usual show, although they do tend to mix things up a bit. There are some songs we’ve heard A LOT (Come Downstairs and Say Hello), but others that we haven’t seen too often. And yet even if we’ve seen most of the songs more than 5 times, there’s nothing like singing along with them and watching them have a blast.
The evening was perfect and they seemed to really enjoy being in Asbury Park (they had recorded their previous album there and had lived in AP for two weeks or so).
This set was interesting for being heavy on Adam-sung songs. He doesn’t sing lead very often anymore, but he used to have a few lead vocals. With Ramona, Demons Center of Attention.
The one thing that we missed in the Eras tour was that they didn’t play many songs of their newest album. The first Eras night they played new songs but we didn’t know them yet. So this was a good opportunity to hear When We Were Stars and The Elevator (for the first time!). Mid way through the show, someone in the front requested Mona Lisa. Ryan said they would play it and then said–wait, let us play it as the encore becaue we have the setlist set up already.
So they opened the encore with it (it was supposed to be Black Balloon, which I would rather have heard). After a super fun Satellite, they called The Mountain Goats back up on stage and they all sang The Lido Shuffle. It was fun and wild and everyone sang along to the Woah oh oh oh part. Curiously, it was only a few days ago that I discovered that this song was not an Elton John song like I’d always assumed (I mean it sounds o much like him) but actually a song by Boz Scaggs. I couldn’t believe they busted it out. I also found out that it was played again the following night at the Summer Stage for Yacht Rock Review. Same sing two nights in a row–I’ll be the Yacht Rock version sounded quite different.
One of the fun things about Guster (of many) is their mid set improv. Tonight’s was all about how you could buy Jello Shots at the venue. He said, only at the Jersey Shore! So he sang a little song about Jello Shots (pop pop) and late during Doin’ It By Myself he walked through the audeince and grabbed Jello Shots for the band (they were disgusting apparently).
The show could have gone on and on as far as I was concerned but I suspect there’s a curfew. When the show was over, my wife grabbed a setlist (very cool) and we sat on the boardwalk looking at the ocean. A woman on stilts (dressed in black and white with seven foot long pants over her stilts) walked the board walk and took pictures with people.
And then we went for Mogo Tacos and they were delicious.
That makes 13 times for me seeing Guster. I’ve seen Phish 17 times. It’s possible that Guster will overtake them since a Guster show is always a much lower key affair (and less work) than a Phish show.
|
|
8/1/2025–Stone Pony Summerstage |
|
|
Careful © [6] |
|
|
What You Call Love ω [5] |
|
|
Ramona © [8] |
|
|
One Man Wrecking Machine ⊗ [4] |
|
|
When We Were Stars Ø [2] |
|
|
Demons ℵ [9] |
|
|
Center of Attention ≅ [3] |
|
|
When You Go Quiet £ [2] |
|
|
Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [12] |
|
|
Do You Love Me ω [9] |
|
|
Hang On ⊗ [7] |
|
|
Jell-O Shots (improv after noticing Jello shots for sale “only at the Stone Pony”) |
|
|
Doin’ It By Myself € [10] (Ryan walked through the audience and grabbed a Jello shot for everyone on stage) |
|
|
The Elevator Ø |
|
|
Amsterdam © [6] |
|
|
Happier ≅ [9] |
|
|
encore |
|
|
Mona Lisa ¶ [3] (fan requested the song earlier, they agreed to play it in the encore–Black Balloon on setlist) |
|
|
Satellite ⊗ [10] |
|
|
Lido Shuffle (Boz Scaggs cover) (with The Mountain Goats) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 3/26/2024–Fillmore Philadelphia ERAs tour |
3/26/2024–Red Bank ERAs Tour |
4/6/ 2023–White Eagle Hall |
8/10/2022–Wellmont |
| Sketch 1: Dorm Room
Parachute ¶ [3] (Ryan & Adam only)
|
Sketch 1: Dorm Room
Parachute ¶ [2] (Ryan & Adam only)
|
What You Wish For ≅ [3] |
Careful © [3] |
| Sketch 2: Enter Brian
Happy Frappy ¶ [2]
|
Sketch 2: Enter Brian
Fall in Two ¶
|
Architects & Engineers ω [3] |
Terrified £ [3] |
| Sketch 3: Harvard Square
X Ray Eyes ℵ
|
Sketch 3: Harvard Square
Demons ℵ [8]
|
Red Oyster Cult © [3] |
Diane © [3] |
| Airport Song ℵ [9] |
Airport Song ℵ [8] |
Ramona © [7] |
Hercules ω [3] |
| Sketch 4: Lillywhite
What You Wish For ≅ [5]
|
Sketch 4: Lillywhite
What You Wish For ≅ [4]
|
One Man Wrecking Machine ⊗ [2] (first since 2015) |
Hang On ⊗ [4] |
| I Spy ≅ [7] |
I Spy ≅ [6] |
Manifest Destiny ⊗ [6] |
Barrel of a Gun ≅ [7] |
| Barrel of a Gun ≅ [9] |
Barrel of a Gun ≅ [8] |
I Hope Tomorrow Is Like Today © [1] |
Backyard © [3] |
| Sketch 5: Tour Bus
Jesus on the Radio (Acoustic) © [5]
|
Sketch 5: Tour Bus
Jesus on the Radio (Acoustic) © [4]
|
All the Way Up to Heaven ≅ [3] |
Satellite (House PA goes out at the end of the song due to power outage.) ⊗ [8] |
| Sketch 6: Joe Joins the Band
Diane © [4]
|
Sketch 6: Joe Joins the Band
Diane © [3]
|
Satellite ⊗ [9] |
Jesus on the Radio (Acoustic) © [3] |
| Careful © [5] |
Careful © [4] |
Doin’ It By Myself (Ryan sang while walking amongst the crowd) € [7] |
Hard Times (Acoustic) £ [2] |
|
(Nothing but) Flowers
(Talking Heads cover) [2]
|
(Nothing but) Flowers
(Talking Heads cover)
|
Look Alive £ [3] |
Parachute (Acoustic) ¶ |
| Hang On ⊗ [6] |
One Man Wrecking Machine ⊗ [3] |
Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [9] |
Doin’ It By Myself (Ryan sang while walking amongst the crowd) € [6] |
| Manifest Destiny ⊗ [6] |
Satellite ⊗ [8] |
Do You Love Me ω [7] |
Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [8] |
| Satellite ⊗ [9] |
The Captain ⊗ [5] |
Never Coming Down € [4] |
Lazy Love € [3] |
| Sketch 7: Evil Producer
Thunder Song [2]
|
Sketch 7: Evil Producer
Thunder Song
|
When You Go Quiet £ (bonus track) |
The New Underground ⊗ |
| Act 2
Do You Love Me ω [8]
|
Act 2
Do You Love Me ω [7]
|
Mexican Restaurant Penis TV Improv Jam to Bon Jovi’s Livin On A Prayer |
Lightning Rod ⊗ [2] |
| Sketch 8: Joe Leaves the Band
Architects and Engineers ω [4]
|
Sketch 8: Joe Leaves the Band
This Could All be Yours ω [6]
|
Airport Song ℵ [7] |
What You Call Love (with 11 year old Sam on bagpipes) ω [4] |
| Luke Reynolds is the Man song |
Luke Reynolds is the Man song |
Happier ≅ [6] |
I Spy ≅ [5] |
| This Could All be Yours ω [6] |
Lost at Sea ω [bonus track] |
Hard Times (with Karina Rykman) £ [3] |
Don’t Go £ |
| Long Night € [5] |
Gangway € [3] |
Psycho Killer (with Karina Rykman band) [Talking Heads cover] |
Ramona © [6] |
| Doin’ It By Myself (Ryan sang while walking amongst the crowd) € [9] |
Doin’ It By Myself (Ryan sang while walking amongst the crowd) € [8] |
Groove is in the Heart (with Karina Rykman band) [Deee-Lite] |
The Captain ⊗ [4] |
Sketch 9: Dave Gets Mad/Appreciated
Dave Song
Don’t Go £ [3]
|
Sketch 9: Dave Gets Mad/Appreciated
Don’t Go £ [2]
|
encore |
Demons ℵ [7] |
| Terrified £ [6] |
Terrified £ [5] |
Mona Lisa ¶ [3] |
encore |
| Sketch 10: COVID
When We Were Stars Ø
|
Sketch 10: COVID
Keep Going Ø
|
Bury Me ¶ |
Do You Love Me ω [6] |
| Black Balloon Ø [2] |
Black Balloon Ø |
Terrified £ [4] |
|
| Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [11] |
Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [10] |
encore 2 |
|
|
Encore: Dumpster Set
|
Encore: Camp Fire Set
|
Hang On ⊗ [5] |
|
|
Happier ≅ [8]
|
Happier ≅ [7]
|
|
|
| Amsterdam © [5] |
Amsterdam © [4] |
|
|
| 3/23/2019–Fillmore |
1/11/2019–Free at Noon |
11/1/2018–White Eagle Hall |
| Diane © [2] |
Hard Times £ |
Long Night € [4] |
| The Captain ⊗ [3] |
Ramona © [5] |
Happier ≅ [4] |
| Terrified £ [2] |
Mind Kontrol £ [2] |
What You Call Love ω [3] |
| Airport Song ℵ [6] |
Manifest Destiny ⊗ [5] |
I Spy (haven’t heard since 2004) ≅ [2] |
| Gangway € [2] |
Terrified £ |
Endlessly € [2] |
| Hello Mister Sun (w/horns) £ [2] |
Look Alive £ |
Airport Song ℵ [5] |
| Overexcited (w/horns) £ [2] |
Satellite ⊗ [6] |
Hello Mr. Sun (new) £ |
| Stay with Me Jesus ω [3] |
Overexcited £ |
Stay With Me Jesus ω [2] |
| Satellite ⊗ [7] |
encore |
Doin’ It By Myself € [4] |
| Doin’ It By Myself (w/horns) € [5] |
I Spy (not broadcast) acoustic ≅ [3] |
improv Levi’s bar mitzvah |
| Look Alive £ [2] |
|
Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [6] |
| Backyard (w/strings} © [2] |
** from the new album |
Do You Love Me ω [5] |
| Amsterdam © [3] |
|
Rocketship (never before) ℵ |
| Window (w/strings & showed the original music video) ¶ |
|
Manifest Destiny ⊗ [4] |
LOST AND GONE FOREVER
20th ANNIVERSARY SET |
|
Amsterdam (not since 2004) © [2] |
| What You Wish For ≅ [2] |
|
Ruby Falls ⊗ [2] |
| Barrel of a Gun ≅ [6] |
|
Ramona © [4] |
| Either Way (w/strings) ≅ |
|
Satellite ⊗ [5] |
| Fa Fa (w/horns & Stephen on flute) ≅ [3] |
|
Barrel of a Gun ≅ [5] |
| I Spy ≅ [4] |
|
improv-“False encore” song |
| Center of Attention ≅ [2] |
|
This Could All be Yours ω [5] |
| All the Way Up to Heaven (not since 2004) ≅ [2] |
|
“encore“ |
| Happier ≅ [5] |
|
Mind Kontrol (new) £ |
| So Long (w/strings) ≅ |
|
Two Points for Honesty ≅ [3] |
| Two Points for Honesty (w/strings) ≅ [4] |
|
Demons ℵ [6] |
| Rainy Day (w/strings) |
|
2nd encore |
| encore |
|
Jesus on the Radio (acoustic, no mics) © [2] |
| Rocketship (w/strings) ℵ [2] |
|
|
| Hang On ⊗ [3] |
|
|
| Great Escape ℵ |
|
|
| Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [7] |
|
|
| 6/16/2016–Fillmore |
11/21/2015–Wellmont |
4/24/2015–TLA |
What You Wish For ≅
|
Ramona © [2] |
Demons ℵ [3] |
| Satellite ⊗ [4] |
Satellite ⊗ [3] |
Center of Attention ≅ |
Doin’ It By Myself € [3]
|
Simple Machine € [2] |
Doin’ It By Myself € |
Barrel of a Gun ≅ [4]
|
Happier ≅ [3] |
The Beginning of the End ⊗ |
| Ramona © [3] |
Hercules ω [2] |
Ramona © |
| Never Coming Down € [3] |
Careful / “Chariots of Fire” © [2] |
Gangway € |
| Architects & Engineers ω [2] |
Doin’ It By Myself € [2] |
Endlessly € |
| Lightning Rod ⊗ [2] |
The Captain ⊗ [2] |
Stay with Me Jesus ω |
| Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [5] |
Kid Dreams € |
Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [3] |
| Do You Love Me ω [4] |
Homecoming King © [2] |
Do You Love Me ω [2] |
Dear Valentine ⊗
|
Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [4] |
(Everything I Do) I Do It for You [Bryan Adams cover] |
That’s No Way to Get to Heaven ω
|
Do You Love Me ω [3] |
Hang On ⊗ [2] |
| Red Oyster Cult © [2] |
Never Coming Down € [2] |
Lazy Love € |
Mona Lisa ¶ [2]
|
Demons ℵ [4] |
Hercules (with Kishi Bashi) ω |
Manifest Destiny ⊗[3]
|
Two Points for Honesty ≅ [2] |
Satellite (with Kishi Bashi) ⊗ [2] |
| Simple Machine € [3] |
Happy Frappy ¶ |
Simple Machine € |
Airport Song ℵ [4]
|
Ruby Falls ⊗ |
Never Coming Down € |
Kid Dreams €[2]
|
Lazy Love € [2] |
Two Points for Honesty ≅ |
| Demons ℵ [5] |
Barrel of a Gun≅ [3] |
Diane © |
| This Could All Be Yours ω [4] |
This Could All Be Yours ω [3] |
Careful © |
encore “Improv”
|
“encore” (“Zombie Jews”) |
This Could All Be Yours ω [2] |
Long Night € [3]
|
Long Night € [2] |
“encore” |
Bad Bad World ω
|
One Man Wrecking Machine ⊗ |
Long Night € |
What You Call Love ω [2]
|
Manifest Destiny ⊗ [2] |
Manifest Destiny ⊗ |
| Fa Fa ≅ [2] |
Airport Song ℵ [3] |
What You Call Love ω |
| encore “boooo” |
Careless Whisper [George Michael cover] |
Happier ≅ [2] |
| Jesus on the Radio © |
|
|
|
|
|
|
7/20/2013–PNC Bank Center |
7/5/2004–Starland |
|
The Captain ⊗ |
Happier ≅ |
|
Architects & Engineers ω |
I Spy ≅ |
|
Homecoming King © |
Airport Song ℵ |
|
Come Downstairs and Say Hello © [2] |
Demons ℵ |
|
Do You Love Me ω |
Amsterdam © |
|
Airport Song ℵ [2] |
Come Downstairs and Say Hello © |
|
Hang On ⊗ |
Barrel of a Gun ≅ |
|
Demons ℵ [2] |
Mona Lisa ¶ |
|
Satellite ⊗ |
Red Oyster Cult © |
|
Barrel of a Gun (with Ed Robertson) ≅ [2] |
California Dreamin’ [Beach Boys cover] |
|
This Could All Be Yours ω |
Fa Fa ≅ |
|
|
Jam (with Ben Folds) |
|
|
Backyard (with Ben Folds) © |
|
|
All the Way Up to Heaven ≅ |
Ø Oh La La (2024) -7/10
£ Look Alive (2019) -2/10
€ Evermotion (2015) -3/11
ω Easy Wonderful (2010) -4/12
⊗ Ganging Up on the Sun (2006) -2/12
© Keep It Together (2003) -3/13
≅ Lost and Gone Forever (1999) —
ℵ Goldfly (1997) -5/11
¶ Parachute (1995) -6/11
Parachute
- “Love for Me”
- “Eden”
- “Scars & Stitches”
- “The Prize”
- “Dissolve”
- “Cocoon”
Goldfly
- “Perfect”
- “Medicine”
- “Grin”
- “Getting Even”
- “Melanie” (unlisted bonus track)
Keep It Together
- “Keep It Together”
- “Long Way Down”
- “Two at a Time” (hidden track)
Ganging Up on the Sun
- “C’mon” – 3:51
- “Empire State” – 4:59
Easy Wonderful
- “On the Ocean”
- “This Is How It Feels to Have a Broken Heart”
- “Jesus and Mary”
- “Do What You Want”
Evermotion
- “Expectation”
- “It Is Just What It Is”
- “Farewell”
Look Alive
- “Summertime”
- “Not for Nothing”
Read Full Post »